| Year | Round | Opponent | Result |
 |
|||
| 2012 | World Series | San Francisco Giants | Lost, 0-4 |
|
|||
| AL Championship Series | New York Yankees | Won, 4-0 | |
|
|||
| AL Division Series | Oakland Athletics | Won, 3-2 | |
|
|||
| 2011 | AL Championship Series | Texas Rangers | Lost, 2-4 |
|
|||
| AL Division Series | New York Yankees | Won, 3-2 | |
|
|||
| 2006 | World Series | St. Louis Cardinals | Lost, 1-4 |
|
|||
| AL Championship Series | Oakland Athletics | Won, 4-0 | |
|
|||
| AL Division Series | New York Yankees | Won, 3-1 | |
|
|||
| 1987 | AL Championship Series | Minnesota Twins | Lost, 1-4 |
|
|||
| 1984 | World Series | San Diego Padres | Won, 4-1 |
|
|||
| AL Championship Series | Kansas City Royals | Won, 3-0 | |
|
|||
| 1972 | AL Championship Series | Oakland Athletics | Lost, 2-3 |
|
|||
| 1968 | World Series | St. Louis Cardinals | Won, 4-3 |
|
|||
| 1945 | World Series | Chicago Cubs | Won, 4-3 |
|
|||
| 1940 | World Series | Cincinnati Reds | Lost, 3-4 |
|
|||
| 1935 | World Series | Chicago Cubs | Won, 4-2 |
|
|||
| 1934 | World Series | St. Louis Cardinals | Lost, 3-4 |
|
|||
| 1909 | World Series | Pittsburgh Pirates | Lost, 3-4 |
|
|||
| 1908 | World Series | Chicago Cubs | Lost, 1-4 |
|
|||
| 1907 | World Series | Chicago Cubs | Lost, 0-4 |
