05/19/08 7:10 PM ET
Fantasy 411 chat wrap, 5/19
By / MLB.com
Mike Siano: Hey everyone we are at my desk and ready to rock out so start getting those questions in and we'll be with you in just a minute.
parkercbc: Have volquez, think he has peaked, want to know who you would target in a trade?
boyland: Is Edinson Volquez for real?
Mike: Seems like Big Ed is a hot topic and he should be since he leads the land in ERA. I think he is legit but if you can sell high for a bat or a Sabathia type I would still do it.
052999: Will Rich Hill make it back by mid June?
Cory Schwartz: I wouldn't be holding my breath for him. He continues to have control troubles in the minors and Lou Piniella isn't the type to let anyone out of the doghouse too quickly. Hill will be back at some point, but remember, he's already 28, not a prospect... in non-keeper leagues, you can move on.
dinoooooo: Should I start Yunel Escobar or Stephen Drew?? Todd Jones or Scott Kazmir? (Saves worth same as wins)
Mike: I have to eat some crow so far on Escobar he is better then I thought. Jones will have more chances at saves then Kazmir wins you would assume but Kazmir is the superior player.
miggs36: Mark Reynolds is on the waiver wire. I currently have Edwin Encarnacion as my corner with Swisher riding pine b/c he is atrocious. Would drop either one for Mark Reynolds?
Cory: I'd stick with the guys you have. Encarnacion has been streaky but will have the numbers when all is said and done, and Swisher is still in his peak and playing in that great hitter's park. Reynolds is waaaayyyy too strikeout prone and will have Chad Tracy looking over his shoulder soon, too.
shawnnnnn: Does the 'hitters hit' philosophy apply to a guy like Gary Sheffield this season?
Mike: Shawn that's a good question. the answer is hitters hit when they are healhty and not old like Sheffield. If he goes on the DL and comes back with a clean bill of health then the philosophy would apply. Keep an eye out for Jeff Larish who is ripping apart the minors for Detroit.
everett03: I have Brad Hawpe and was wondering if I should try to trade him to get Swisher since I know you guys are low on Hawpe. Thanks for your help!!
Cory: I would do this deal. Hawpe is very heavily dependent on Coors and can't hit lefties, while Swisher has shown ability to hit from both sides, and also plays in a great hitters park. Neither are hitting right now but I'd take my chances on Swisher from here on out, especially if the Rockies start to trade off some guys and rebuild.
scottymack: Hey guys, I'm looking to upgrade offense in my AL-only league. Would you deal either Vazquez or Beckett along with Thome & Dellucci for AJ Burnett, Sheffield and either BJ Upton or Ichiro?
Mike: I would definitely make a strong effort to get Upton or Ichiro but I think you keep it simple and do a 2 for 1 or one for one. if you afford to move Beckett then make the 1 for 1 but keep most of these names out of it.
itsrvd: Rank these 3: Greinke, Cain, Scherzer.
Cory: For this year I would go Greinke, Cain, Scherzer. Long term I would put Scherzer ahead of Cain, once his role gets figured out. This is no knock on Cain, but the Giants are just a brutally bad team and are not going to get better.
ionlywin: I have A question, not even about helping me in my league because I am in first, but how do you get to the point where you are getting paid to give advice in fantasy?
Mike: Create your own site and figure out a way to get people to visit it and hope you are good or get an internship at an MLB.com, ESPN, CBS, Yahoo or with the Shandler's and Lawr Michaels of the land. We do this for free btw.
Cory: Make friends with Andy Roth and hope he hires you. He was foolish enough to give me my first shot.
ronaldo07: Hello from England! Im playing the MLB.com Fantasy Open, and am torn between who to start, Guzman or S. Drew from the Diamondbacks?
Cory: Guzman has been a surprisingly solid contributor this year, but Drew is a better hitter and plays for a better team in a better ballpark. Stick with the skillz.
stu61: Is Johnny Cueto a good buy low candidate?
Mike: Depends what you are paying, but sure I'd take Cueto and prepare for some so so starts.
kbalderston: Hey guys, what should I do with Lastings Millege in a vanilla league. Drop him or stash him?
Cory: As much as I like Milledge and believe in his talent, he can be dropped right now in a non-keeper mixed league. I think he'll be a contributor before all is said and done but right now I'd rather go for someone who is, y'know, hitting a little bit.
miggs36: I have held onto Chase Headley and he is taking up one of just 4 reserve spots in my 11 team league. I have kept him this long and hope my patience will be rewarded. Do you see him getting called up anytime soon, and if so, will I reap the benefits?
rokhed: When is Chase headley going to be called up?
Mike: I honestly was surprised he didn't get called up when Edmonds got released. It is just a matter of time, the Padres are underacheiving and could use Chse over Gerut 10 times a week. Hang in there if you can.
claybo7: Will Adam Laroche get called up soon? will he recieve regular AB's?
Cory: Presumably you mean Andy, Adam's little brother who is in Triple-A with the Dodgers. He's still on the mend from his spring injury, and with Blake DeWitt hitting well, there's no rush to bring him up. LaRoche is still the long-term answer at third for the Dodgers, though.
ronaldo07: Dan Uggla is tearing it up for me this season, hes always had the power, but seems to have improved his plate discipline too. Do you think this will last?
Cory: Plate discipline is a skill, so Uggla's improvement in this regard is very, very promising. He's a guy who's been proving a lot of people wrong over the past few years -- me among them -- so I wouldn't doubt this improvement is for real. Remember, he had 49 doubles and 31 homers last year, so the power is legit.
bluevoid: Bartolo Colon makes his return this week. Is he worth picking up?
Cory: Mike owns and already activated Colon in an AL-only league, which makes sense because he'll get the offensive and bullpen support from the Red Sox. But in mixed leagues, I'd be more patient, there are a lot of starters to choose from. He hasn't been healthy or effective for a couple of years.
ilpozzallese: Erv Santana is pitching at Chicago next time out... would you put him in?
Cory: I know I speak for Mike on this one... the way Erv is throwing right now, start him anywhere, anytime, against anyone. The home/road thing seems to be a non-issue now, especially that he's cut his walk rate without losing any strikeouts.
itsrvd: Will Jeff Francoeur pick it up soon? He has 3 homers and 2 were in one game!
mattyboy5: Beltran for j sheilds and francour -- who got the better?
Cory: These two questions fit well together. I like the Shields/Francoeur end of the deal, because Shields is a legit soft ace/#2, and while Francoeur hasn't shown the power yet, the RBI's have been there and the Braves offense is stacked. He hit 43 over the past two years so he should get at least 20 again this year. Beltran is solid but this is a great return.
gdream: Hi Guys, Matt Joyce, Detroit, 4HR/30AB, Is it legit?
Cory: I don't like betting against guys but Joyce seems to me like the AL version of John Bowker. Joyce never hit for any meaningful power in the minors, didn't hit for a great average and didn't walk much. His long-term future is as a 4th/5th OF.
everett03: Someone just dropped Kouz in my 12 team mixed. We have 2 starters at every position and get 5 keepers at the end of the year. I'm sitting at #5 on the waiver wire with Braun, Wigginton, and Castillo (SF) who can play 3B.
Cory: I have Kouz in the 411 listener league and I am losing faith in him; check out his disgusting K/BB rate and low fly-ball rates. But, that said, Castillo is a waiver wire player so if I had to bet on one or the other, it would still be Kouz.
soxfan1997: Will DiceK be 8-0 for the Red Sox?
Cory: His next start is at home against the Royals, so I like his chances. But he has to keep the walks down to continue enjoying this level of success, and that's no guarantee.
astian: When will Liriano be back up? What should we expect from him this year?
Cory: Our good friend Will Carroll at Baseball Prospectus.com had a great writeup on Liriano today and thinks he's finally turning the corner. He'll be back up at some point this year, possibly in the next 2-3 weeks, but after his rough start to the season, expect the Twins to be cautious. Still, a great stash right now in any format.
boyland: Any idea how serious Peavy's elbow is?
Cory: Right now no one is talking anything more than one missed start, but I'm worried. He's had elbow/forearm problems before and recurrence is a very scary thing in my opinion. With the Padres going nowhere fast, it wouldn't surprise me to see him get shut down for some time to let things clear up.
iggy23: Is Dustin Hermanson still a lock for Cinci's closing role?
Cory: Haha, good one! I'll stick by my sources; the guy who gave me this one last year has given me plenty of other good insights. But if we got everything 100% right all the time, we'd all be rolling in Vegas like Jeff Ma, not doing a fantasy baseball chat!
boyland: What about Felix Hernandez? Sometimes he seems like a breakout star and other times he seems to lose his way. What's your take?
Cory: His talent and stuff are incredible, that's obvious, and the home ballpark is a big plus. But his mechanics are inconsistent and that makes him risky, always. High risk, nuclear reward.
052999: Do you think that Eveland and Smith will continue to provide quality starts for the A's or do you think they are starting to fade?
Mike: I think the shine has come off a tad but I'm not writing them off just yet. I would predict Duke losing his slot and Gaudin getting back in there before I would for Smith or Eveland.
fsudan: I am in a 9 person league and in dead last in every offensive category. My sluggers are arod, vladdy, carlos beltran, torri hunter, jason bay, and thome. Should I be worried at this point in the season?
Mike: The magic name is A-Rod. I think all A-Rod owners who are struggling offesnively need to wait a few more weeks and luckily we can. If Alex gets hot like Papi and Soriano have I think you will see yoruself start moving. If he doesn't then by June 5thish you have to start thinking drastic moves to salvage your season. I am optimistic.
pfelon: So far this season, Cliff Lee, Joe Saunders, Ervin Santana, Nate McLouth, and Ryan Church have helped me hang near the top of my 12 team vanilla keeper league. Which of these guys should I be pushing to sell high on, and which will be solid contributors
Mike: Always sell high on arms for bats or stud arms in return. Chruch I think is going to have a solid season front to end and McLouth has to get those steals up and I can't believe his homers continue.
mattyboy5: What's going on with the Reds OF, Griff gettin traded maybe dunn too, bruce tearing up the minors?
saxnchi: How much FAB do you think it will cost for Jay Bruce in a 10 team NL only 5x5? We can not bid until he is called up. - Sax from Chicago
Cory: Griffey may or may not be trade bait, but the Patterson/Freel platoon is really where Bruce can make an impact. There's no doubt he can help the Reds right now, but I will stick by my original guess that he comes up on or around June 12. Whenever he does, get ready to spend your entire FAAB budget, because he's that good... as Reds' PR guy Jamie Ramsay notes, Bruce is "currently mired in a 27-for-51 slump." Good stuff.
pfelon: Can Clint Barmes continue this hot start?
Cory: I just picked up Barmes this week in NFBC since they are home all week. I don't think he'll hit .360, but he has some pop and speed and can help in most formats.
Cory: BTW, pfelon, I think you would be wise to put Barmes in your lineup.
BB-King:With 5 bench spots in a daily 12 team 5x5. How do you split the bench between hitters and pitchers?
Mike: I would go mostly bats so you aren't left scrambling for scraps on Monday's and Thursday's. With five spots I wouldn't be against stashing a prospect like Bruce or Headley instead of an arm, just pitch or ditch.
zmun: Your opinion on kobyashi and perez for saves?
Mike: I said on today's show that I'm not buying into Koby , Borowski is going to get his job back in the next 7 - 14 days so this coulkd be a lot of work for not a lot of saves. Didn't help he looked terrrible against Reds Saturday.
yankeeduke: max scherzer/carlos marmol, outlook for the rest of the year, who is more valuable in a regular H2H league?
Cory: Marmol has been awesome this year, but Wood has done nothing to suggest he won't be solid all year, and Piniella might really wear down Marmol's arm. Scherzer's role isn't well-defined right now but I've seen enough so far to think he'll be the choice here, simply because he'll probably end up throwing more innings.
bluevoid: Where do you rank Kurt Suzuki? Is he good enough to be a #1 catcher in a 12 team leauge?
Cory: Sorry, I don't think so. He has a little pop and might steal the occasional bag, but won't hit for much average, especially in that home ballpark. Long-term I'd still rather have JR Towles, and he's hitting .154!
claybo7: 11 team 5x5 mixed keeper. Have weeks at 2b, h ram at SS, and betencourt at MI. Would you drop weeks for Durham, F Sanchez, L Castiillo, Iguchi, or R Vazquez? Weeks BA is killing me
Cory: You can't drop Weeks, he contributes nicely in the other four categories. Yuniesky is the guy hurting you, and I'd go for Durham (hot now) or Sanchez (best long-term option) over him.
janingla: Guys, need help in evaluating this trade. 15 team 5x5 mixed. I would give up Bedard and Big Erv and get Mauer, Francis and Cliff Lee. Should i do it?
Mike: Tough call but I probably wouldn't. I like that you get Mauer without giving up a bat but pound for pound it's proabbly not worth the hit you take in pitching.
ronaldo07: I have a quandry - who to start between Burrell or Abreu? I have McLouth and Quentin as my other 2 OFs but cannot make my mind up between burrell and abreu who both seem to have gone cold?
Mike: Make a trade! Burrel has 7 games but is on the road. yanks have 6 but are home. I go Abreu but Cory goes burrell so flip a coin or go with your gut. Great problem to have.
iggy23: Will Bonds get picked up as a DH this year?
Mike: team that makes the most sene is Detroit if Sheff goes on shelf and they decide to not call up larish.
gdream: Guerrero, LAA, subpar numbers, is it time to use him as trade bait?
Cory: You won't find many bigger Vladdy fans than me, but he's clearly a player in decline. That said, he hit .324/27/125 last year, so he should still rebound and put up some good numbers this year. But his years of being a first-round pick are over, and the second round may be out too.
everett03: When do you guys think Kershaw is going to get brought up?
Cory: Like Jay Bruce, I'll stick with June 12. He's doing fine in Triple-A but the Dodgers are doing fine too so there's no need to rush him, he's only 20 years old. When he's up though, it will almost certainly be for good. Save your FAAB dollars, you're gonna need 'em.
monq24: What's wrong with jeff francis?
Mike: Nothing, he's just not a great pitcher.
epsteine: Should I drop Jason Isringhausen?
Mike: I wouldn't he is on DL and will be the closer again at least once more.
Cory: I agree Izzy will get another shot at the closer job, but we've said many times recently that Chris Perez is the future there, and he's up now, so he's definitely worth picking up in deeper and/or keeper leagues. Big guy with a big-time arm.
yankeeduke: Hunter Pence for Adam Dunn/Marmol, good deal, outlooks?
Mike: I'd do it.
fsudan: Do you think that ervin santana and micah owings will keep up what they are doing?
Mike: I have more faith in Big Erv, Owings is good but his window is smaller due to davis coming back and Scherzer looking muy bueno.
1fukudome: Hey guys, What do you think of Helton's lack of power lately? I was thinking of packaging him with a reliever like Rivera or Capps to get D. Lee. or should I stick it out.
Cory: For all the other good stuff he does, Helton has only averaged 17 homers for the past three seasons, so this is no fluke. Helton and Capps for Lee is a very reasonable and fair offer, but I wouldn't include Mariano in that deal. He's still among the elite.
boyland: Should I trade Edgar Renteria for Corey Hart?
Cory: I would do this deal. I've said all winter that the Tigers offense was overrated and fragile, and while Hart hasn't picked up the power yet, he's hitting over .300 and providing steals. This one will pay off in the long run.
gdream: What's going on with the Chisox hitters, Thome, Kornerko and Swisher are all of pace?
Mike: Wish I knew, it's a mystery because all are good hitters that are slumping terribly at the same time. They will all come around and get back to or close to pace is my guess.
jkulczycki: Keeper league who would you rather have - Miguel Cabrera or Ryan Braun?
Mike: Braun, he is younger and plays in a better park and steals with power, but that's me.
Cory: OTOH, Cabrera is probably the better overall hitter, and will be 1B and 3B eligible, compared to OF only for Braun. Tough choice, you can't go wrong.
parkercbc: What is your take on Josh Hamilton? Legit or time to sell high?
Cory: Very tough read here. Pros: improved walk rate, great home park, 30 HR in fewer than 162 career games, AL pitchers still learning him. Con: Clearly overachieving in RBI, still has to learn AL pitchers, not a great lineup around him, may be at his peak value. I'd deal him, but get full value in return as opposed to "cashing on" on a sell-high.
yidgator: How much more patience would you have with JR Towles and Andrew Jones?
Mike: Towles was cut in 411 league and is still out there and Jones is close to that which is mind boggling, at least Towles is a rookie.
Cory: Don't give up on Towles just yet though... he's not strking out much and has legit power. He could bounce back and provide real value in deeper leagues.
rokhed: Is Paul Byrd a quality 5th starter in a 14 team, 25 man roster mixed league? woiuld you start him ahead of Hochevar?
Mike: Byrd has minimal value in that format and no I wouldn't start him over Luke, only problem with Luke is he has the Red Sox tonight.
champs31: What do you think of Ramon Vasquez at shortstop because my starter is out in Rafael Furcal?
Mike: Furcal will be back Friday accoridng to Uncle Joe Torre, but Vazquez is a fine fill in for the time being especially now that Blalock is playing 1B when he returns.
miggs36: Great show fellas. 11 team 5X5 Mixed League-Please evaluate this trade:I need hitting help and have decent depth at pitching.I traded James Shields, Jair Jurrjens, and Gary Sheffield for Vlad Guerrero and Shane Victorino.
Cory: Thanks! I think this is a decent trade; break it down like this... Sheff and Jurrjens for Vlad is a solid deal, and Shields for Victorino is pretty solid too. If Sheff gets healthy and starts hitting again this might sting a little, but then again, Jurrjens is not a guarantee just yet.
giantyank: Will Garret Anderson continue his hot streak this week and will O.Cabrera light up his old team?
Cory: Over the past four years Anderson has averaged 17 homers and 84 RBI's. That's nice production, but nothing to get too worked up over. I'd rather have Cabrera from now to the end of the season, because he's a shortstop and will steal some bags.
kcfrog: What's up guys? Which struggling starter do you have more faith in - Brett Myers or Justin Verlander? Thanks - KC
Cory: I'd go with Verlander: younger, better home park, better velocity, fewer HR problems, less mileage on his arm... all signs point to Verlander here. Myers has lost his velocity and as yet there's no indication it's coming back.
monq24: Which is a better bet: suppan or lannan?
Mike: Strong Island's own John Lannan is having himself quite the nice little season so far. Go for it.
thesloths1: What do you think about Cliff Lee bouncing back from his last start and being a top tier starter for the remainder of 08?
Mike: Sloth take it easy, did you really expect Clifford to pitch like he had been all season long? Be happy he proved he is human.
bffools: would you trade Reyes For A. Pujols in a Keeper league
Mike: No beucase eventually Albert will need surgery and Reyes goes before him in drafts anyway.
Cory: BTW folks we are going to go another 15 minutes or so, so let's start speed round now...
jesseatcal: Hey guys - wanted to know your opinion on the value of the pure steals guys. Thinking of trading Rauch (and cordero) for Gomez? Thoughts? I don't usually go for these guys, but have been caught a little unawares by the huge number of steals so far this season.
Cory: Gomez is not a great baseball player, but when he gets on, he steals. This is fair value if it fits the needs.
iggy23: Will Bartolo Colon be worth of a waiver claim in my 12 team mixed league? I need pitching help.
Mike: Maybe but dont expect great things just yet his pitch count is low right now.
miggs36: Are lowe and myers this atrocious? I dumped Arroyo in less time and am wondering when I should pull the plug on these two as they have singlehandedly destroyed my era.
Cory: They just might be. Lowe has been banged up and has never been great -- good, but not great -- so he's replacable. As noted above, Myers has gone from homer prone to a bad batting practice pitcher, and he doesn't have enough of a repertoire to survive at 88-89 MPH. In time they may bounce back but how long can you wait? I've moved on.
monq24: Will james loney's power numbers improve?
Mike: I think so. I never had him pegged for more then 25 but he has to get pretty hot to meet that. Let's put him at 20 right now so 5 off my pace.
the_beef: I am in need of RBIs ....Ive been offered Burrel for my Bay. What do you say?
Cory: Bay has been heating up but the lineup around him isn't nearly as good as the Phillies. There's some risk here but it's an upgrade at least as far as RBI's go.
arthardie: Is Mike Cameron a smart fantasy pickup this year?
Mike: Will provide pop and speed in a good lineup. Don't expect much average and you'll be ok.
bigsprung: If you have a struggling offense, would you trade Jeff Francis for either Xavier Nady or Ryan Church, if so explain why.
Mike: Francis is just not a great fantasy pitcher it's that simple. He pitches in Coors and if anything has been overrated. I like Church over Nady but I'd take either in a second over Francis.
crasyhors: With Doug Davis returning, will max Sherzer stay in the rotation?
Cory: As noted on today's show, talent wins out, and Scherzer was dominant in his three starts minus one bad inning against the Phillies. He may go to the 'pen for now but he's shown he'll have value all year.
parkercbc: What is a fair expectation for Josh Hamilton at the end of the year? Obviously he can't sustain this pace. Is he legit?
Cory: I'd bump up my expectations to .280/32/115, maybe a little more, but remember also he hasn't proven he can stay healthy over a full season. As Big Tuna would say, let's not get out the anointing oils just yet!
hlwdjsd: Working ont a trade in a 5x5 keeper league. I desperately need steals. I'm trading from SP strength -- so far we have Lincecum & Verlander for Figgins and ? What kind of player would finish that up?
Mike: HOFer Jeanne!!!
Mike: Tough one Jeanne. We prefer you just did one for one. Verlander for Figgins and move on?
iggy23: I have a non baseball related question? Who cuts your hair?
Mike: Flo-bee , it still works , plutonium is awesome!!!!!
Cory: Uncle Ernie's barbershop on Merrick Avenue. Shave, too!
Mike: I actually see a russian assasin name Mikail at a Long Beach lemon tree.
bigsprung: How long could Jake Peavy be out for, I heard John Kruk say that the Padres should just shut him down.
Mike and Cory: let's wait on the MRI really have no choice, but be prepared to be without him.
GunSlinger: Should I start Arroyo tonight?
Mike and Cory: We both say pitch, I think he got pissed at the Club DTM reference. Great call by Todd Zola so far that Arroyo would bounce back.
Mike and Cory: thanks everyone we'll see yout tomorrow at 2pm ET for the Tuesday showgram.
This story was not subject to the approval of Major League Baseball or its clubs.