Teams 
 | ||
| Name | Years managed | Record |
| ||
| Joe Girardi | Present | |
| ||
| Joe Torre | 1996-2007 | 1,173-767 |
| ||
| Buck Showalter | 1992-95 | 313-268 |
| ||
| Stump Merrill | 1990-91 | 120-155 |
| ||
| Bucky Dent | 1989-90 | 36-53 |
| ||
| Dallas Green | 1989 | 56-65 |
| ||
| Lou Piniella | 1986-87, 1988 | 224-193 |
| ||
| Clyde King | 1982 | 29-33 |
| ||
| Gene Michael | 1981, 1982 | 92-76 |
| ||
| Dick Howser | 1980 | 103-60 |
| ||
| Bob Lemon | 1978-79, 1981-82 | 99-73 |
| ||
| Billy Martin | 1975-78, 1979, 1983, 1985, 1988 | 556-385 |
| ||
| Bill Virdon | 1974-75 | 142-124 |
| ||
| Johnny Keane | 1965-66 | 81-101 |
| ||
| Yogi Berra | 1964, 1984-85 | 192-148 |
| ||
| Ralph Houk | 1961-63, 1966-73 | 944-806 |
| ||
| Casey Stengel | 1949-60 | 1,149-696 |
| ||
| Bucky Harris | 1947-48 | 191-117 |
| ||
| Johnny Neun | 1946 | 8-6 |
| ||
| Bill Dickey | 1946 | 57-48 |
| ||
| Joe McCarthy | 1931-46 | 1,460-867 |
| ||
| Bob Shawkey | 1930 | 86-68 |
| ||
| Art Fletcher | 1929 | 6-5 |
| ||
| Miller Huggins | 1918-29 | 1,067-719 |
| ||
| Bill Donovan | 1915-17 | 220-239 |
| ||
| Roger Peckinpaugh | 1914 | 10-10 |
| ||
| Frank Chance | 1913-14 | 117-168 |
| ||
| Harry Wolverton | 1912 | 50-102 |
| ||
| Hal Chase | 1910-11 | 85-78 |
| ||
| George Stallings | 1909-10 | 153-138 |
| ||
| Norm Elberfeld | 1908 | 27-71 |
| ||
| Clark Griffith | 1903-08 | 419-370 |
