| Year | Round | Opponent | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2012 | NL Division Series | Cincinnati | Won 3-2 |
| NL Championship Series | St. Louis | Won 4-3 | |
| World Series | Detroit | Won 4-0 | |
| 2010 | NL Division Series | Atlanta | Won 3-1 |
| NL Championship Series | Philadelphia | Won 4-2 | |
| World Series | Texas | Won 4-1 | |
| 2003 | NL Division Series | Florida | Lost 1-3 | Box Scores » |
| 2002 | World Series | Anaheim | Lost 3-4 | Box Scores » |
| NL Championship Series | St. Louis | Won 4-1 | Box Scores » | |
| NL Division Series | Atlanta | Won 3-2 | Box Scores » | |
| 2000 | NL Division Series | New York | Lost 1-3 | Box Scores » |
| 1997 | NL Division Series | Florida | Lost 0-3 | Box Scores » |
| 1989 | World Series | Oakland | Lost 0-4 | Box Scores » |
| NL Championship Series | Chicago | Won 4-1 | Box Scores » | |
| 1987 | NL Championship Series | St. Louis | Lost 3-4 | Box Scores » |
| 1971 | NL Championship Series | Pittsburgh | Lost 1-3 | Box Scores » |
| 1962 | World Series | New York | Lost 3-4 | Box Scores » |
| 1954 | World Series | Cleveland | Won 4-0 | Box Scores » |
| 1951 | World Series | New York | Lost 2-4 | Box Scores » |
| 1937 | World Series | New York | Lost 1-4 | Box Scores » |
| 1936 | World Series | New York | Lost 2-4 | Box Scores » |
| 1933 | World Series | Washington | Won 4-1 | Box Scores » |
| 1924 | World Series | Washington | Lost 3-4 | Box Scores » |
| 1923 | World Series | New York | Lost 2-4 | Box Scores » |
| 1922 | World Series | New York | Won 4-0-1 | Box Scores » |
| 1921 | World Series | New York | Won 5-3 | Box Scores » |
| 1917 | World Series | Chicago | Lost 2-4 | Box Scores » |
| 1913 | World Series | Philadelphia | Lost 1-4 | Box Scores » |
| 1912 | World Series | Boston | Lost 3-4-1 | Box Scores » |
| 1911 | World Series | Philadelphia | Lost 2-4 | Box Scores » |
| 1905 | World Series | Philadelphia | Won 4-1 | Box Scores » |
