Year | Winner (School) | Finalists (School) |
| 2008 | To Be Determined | Gordon Beckham (Georgia) |
| | Aaron Crow (Missouri) |
| | Brian Matusz (San Diego) |
| | Buster Posey (Florida State) |
| | Brett Wallace (Arizona State) |
| 2007 | David Price, LHP (Vanderbilt) | Pedro Alvarez (Vanderbilt) |
| | Matt LaPorta (Florida) |
| | Kyle Russell (Texas) |
| | Tony Thomas, Jr. (Florida State) |
| 2006 | Tim Lincecum, RHP (Washington) | Evan Longoria (Long Beach State) |
| | Andrew Miller (North Carolina) |
| | David Price (Vanderbilt) |
| | Drew Stubbs (Texas) |
| 2005 | Alex Gordon, 3B (Nebraska) | Ryan Braun (Miami-FL) |
| | Jeff Clement (Southern California) |
| | Trevor Crowe (Arizona) |
| | Luke Hochevar (Tennessee) |
| 2004 | Jered Weaver, RHP (Long Beach State) | Stephen Head (Mississippi) |
| | Dustin Pedroia (Arizona State) |
| | Huston Street (Texas) |
| | Wade Townsend (Rice) |
| 2003 | Rickie Weeks, 2B (Southern) | Michael Aubrey (Tulane) |
| | Carlos Quentin (Stanford) |
| | Kyle Sleeth (Wake Forest) |
| | Tim Stauffer (Richmond) |
| 2002 | Khalil Greene, SS (Clemson) | Russ Adams (North Carolina) |
| | Jeff Baker (Clemson) |
| | Bobby Brownlie (Rutgers) |
| | Jeremy Guthrie (Stanford) |
| 2001 | Mark Prior, RHP (Southern California) | Chris Burke (Tennessee) |
| | Dewon Brazelton (Middle Tennessee State) |
| | John-Ford Griffin (Florida State) |
| | John VanBenschoten (Kent State) |
| 2000 | Kip Bouknight, RHP (South Carolina) | Brad Cresse (Louisiana State) |
| | Beau Hale (Texas) |
| | Mark Teixeira (Georgia Tech) |
| | Justin Wayne (Stanford) |
| 1999 | Jason Jennings, RHP (Baylor) | Ken Harvey (Nebraska) |
| | Bobby Hill (Miami-FL) |
| | Marshall McDougall (Florida State) |
| | Eric Munson (Southern California) |
| 1998 | Pat Burrell, 3B (Miami-FL) | Jeff Austin (Stanford) |
| Program (.pdf) | | Seth Etherton (Southern California) |
| | Eddy Furniss (Louisiana State) |
| | Brad Wilkerson (Florida) |
| 1997 | J.D. Drew, OF (Florida State) | Matt Anderson (Rice) |
| Program (.pdf) | | Lance Berkman (Rice) |
| | Pat Burrell (Miami-FL) |
| | Troy Glaus (UCLA) |
| | Tim Hudson (Auburn) |
| | Adam Kennedy (Cal State Northridge) |
| | Brandon Larson (Louisiana State) |
| | Roberto Vaz (Alabama) |
| 1996 | Travis Lee, 1B (San Diego State) | Kris Benson (Clemson) |
| Program (.pdf) | | Pat Burrell (Miami-FL) |
| | J.D. Drew (Florida State) |
| | Seth Greisinger (Virginia) |
| | A.J. Hinch (Stanford) |
| | Jacque Jones (Southern California) |
| | Mark Kotsay (Cal State Fullerton) |
| | Braden Looper (Wichita State) |
| 1995 | Mark Kotsay, OF (Cal State Fullerton) | Clint Bryant (Texas Tech) |
| | Jose Cruz, Jr. (Rice) |
| | Darin Erstad (Nebraska) |
| | Todd Helton (Tennessee) |
| | Geoff Jenkins (Southern California) |
| | Jonathan Johnson (Florida State) |
| | Shane Monahan (Clemson) |
| | Mark Redman (Oklahoma) |
| 1994 | Jason Varitek, C (Georgia Tech) | Jacob Cruz (Arizona State) |
| Program (.pdf) | | Nomar Garciaparra (Georgia Tech) |
| | Dustin Hermanson (Florida State) |
| | Russ Johnson (Louisiana State) |
| | Jay Payton (Georgia Tech) |
| | John Powell (Auburn) |
| | Todd Walker (Louisiana State) |
| | Paul Wilson (Florida State) |
| 1993 | Darren Dreifort, RHP (Wichita State) | Brian Anderson (Wright State) |
| Program (.pdf) | | Jeff Granger (Texas A&M) |
| | Brooks Kieschnick (Texas) |
| | Paul LoDuca (Arizona State) |
| | John Powell (Auburn) |
| | Alex Rodriguez (Westminster Christian HS) |
| | Jason Varitek (Georgia Tech) |
| | Todd Walker (Louisiana State) |
| 1992 | Phil Nevin, 3B (Cal State Fullerton) | Jeff Alkire (Miami-FL) |
| Program (.pdf) | | Darren Dreifort (Wichita State) |
| | Jeffrey Hammonds (Stanford) |
| | Charles Johnson (Miami-FL) |
| | Brooks Kieschnick (Texas) |
| | Lloyd Peever (Louisiana State) |
| | Mike Smith (Indiana) |
| | Michael Tucker (Longwood) |
| 1991 | Mike Kelly, OF (Arizona State) | Brent Gates (Minnesota) |
| Program (.pdf) | | Charles Johnson (Miami-FL) |
| | Bobby Jones (Fresno State) |
| | David McCarty (Stanford) |
| | Kennie Steenstra (Wichita State) |
| | Phil Stidham (Arkansas) |
| | Mark Sweeney (Maine) |
| | Tom Vantiger (Iowa State) |
| 1990 | Alex Fernandez, RHP (Miami Dade CC) | Tom Costo (Iowa) |
| | Paul Ellis (UCLA) |
| | Dave Fleming (Georgia) |
| | Joey Hamilton (Georgia Southern) |
| | Mike Kelly (Arizona State) |
| | Sam Militello (Tampa) |
| | Oscar Munoz (Miami-FL) |
| | Dan Wilson (Minnesota) |
| 1989 | Ben McDonald, RHP (Louisiana State) | Scott Bryant (Texas) |
| | John Byington (Texas A&M) |
| | Alex Fernandez (Miami Dade CC) |
| | Tom Goodwin (Fresno State) |
| | Dan Peltier (Notre Dame) |
| | Eric Wedge (Wichita State) |
| | Dan Wilson (Minnesota) |
| | Alan Zinter (Arizona) |
| 1988 | Robin Ventura, 3B (Oklahoma State) | Jim Abbott (Michigan) |
| Program (.pdf) | | Andy Benes (Evansville) |
| | Mike Fiore (Miami-FL) |
| | Ty Griffin (Georgia Tech) |
| | Gregg Olson (Auburn) |
| | Tino Martinez (Tampa) |
| | Ed Sprague (Stanford) |
| | Ted Wood (New Orleans) |
| 1987 | Jim Abbott, LHP (Michigan) | Cris Carpenter (Georgia) |
| Program (.pdf) | | Ken Griffey, Jr. (Moeller HS) |
| | Don Guillott (Pan American) |
| | Derek Lilliquist (Georgia) |
| | Jack McDowell (Stanford) |
| | Mike Remlinger (Darmouth) |
| | Marteese Robinson (Seton Hall) |
| | Robin Ventura (Oklahoma State) |
| 1986 | Mike Loynd, RHP (Florida State) | Program (.pdf) |
| | |
| 1985 | Will Clark, 1B (Mississippi State) | Tim Barker (Central Florida) |
| | Chris Gwynn (San Diego State) |
| | Pete Incaviglia (Oklahoma State) |
| | Barry Larkin (Michigan) |
| | Rick Raether (Miami-FL) |
| | B.J. Surhoff (North Carolina) |
| | Greg Swindell (Texas) |
| | John Verducci (Stanford) |
| 1984 | Oddibe McDowell, OF (Arizona State) | Rob Amble (Azusa Pacific) |
| Program (.pdf) | | Scott Bankhead (North Carolina) |
| | Lance Blankenship (California) |
| | Mike Dunne (Bradley) |
| | John Hoover (Fresno State) |
| | Barry Larkin (Michigan) |
| | Mark McGwire (Southern California) |
| | Rafael Palmeiro (Mississippi State) |
| 1983 | Dave Magadan, 1B (Alabama) | Program (.pdf) |
| | |
| 1982 | Augie Schmidt, SS (New Orleans) | Brent Friehauf (Bowie HS) |
| Program (.pdf) | | Jeff Ledbetter (Florida State) |
| | John Morris (Seton Hall) |
| | Jim Paciorik (Michigan) |
| | Tom Scaletta (Cal Poly Pomana) |
| | Mike Trapasso (St. Louis American Legion) |
| 1981 | Mike Fuentes, OF (Florida State) | Program (.pdf) |
| | |
| 1980 | Terry Francona, OF (Arizona) | |
| | |
| 1979 | Tim Wallach, 1B (Cal State Fullerton) | |
| | |
| 1978 | Bob Horner, 3B (Arizona State) | |
| | |
